Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

Disney Subscriber Dive: Disney+’s Ad-Tier, Hulu Isssue, and The Hope for ESPN+

Let’s do a Disney Subscriber Dive.

As I noted in my newsletter, Disney+’s ad-tier is off to a better start than either Netflix or HBO Max among new subscribers. That data point comes from Antenna Data, a data and analytics company that focuses on the subscription economy. (I’ll be referencing Antenna’s work throughout the first part of this piece before transitioning to Disney’s own Q1 data).

In the first month of availability, 20% of new sign-ups for Disney+ were for the ad-tier. Disney outpaced Netflix (9%) and HBO Max (14%) by getting subscribers to subscribe to the ad-tier. By the third month, Disney+ reached a staggering 36% of new sign-ups we’re opting for the ad-supported plan.

The rollout of the Disney+ ad-tier came at a time when Disney increased prices. Subscribers were dealt with a choice of paying the same amount for Disney+ but now having ads or paying an extra $3 a month to go to premium.

Antenna found that 94% of Disney+ Premium plan Subscribers took the price increase, 5% canceled, and less than 1% of existing Subscribers maintained their current cost by switching to the Ad-supported plan.

That is just an unbelievable stat and shows the value of Disney+’s content. 94% decided to take the price increase. Only 1% of existing subscribers decided to convert to ads. It’s clear that subscribers want to watch The Mandalaorian and their Disney movies without ads. Do other streaming services have strong enough brands and content to have this type of loyalty to stay with the premium plan? I guess we will find out in the coming years.

Disney’s overall direct-to-consumer revenue increased 13% from Q1 2022 to Q1 2023. However the operating income loss grew. It went from $600 million to $1.1 billion. Direct-to-consumer is an expensive game, and with content and marketing budgets ballooning, it’s no wonder Disney lost what it did. Disney CEO Bob Iger is now trying to reign in costs through various cost-cutting measures. We’ll likely see the effects of these moves later in the year.

Disney in Q1 2023 lost 2.4 million subscribers but that was mostly because of the steep dropoff in Disney+ Hotstar subscribers. Disney lost the streaming rights to IPL Cricket, so subscribers dropped. The subscriber loss had nothing to do with the the price hike, as many assumed. Disney+ Core subscribers actually increased slightly in Q1 2023. As of that quarter there was 104 million Disney+ Core subscribers. Disney+ Core’s ARPU (average revenue per user) sits at $5.77. That was a 19 cents decrease from the previous quarter and it was due to a higher mix of subscribers going for the Disney Bundle. Disney+ Hotstar accounts for 57 million subscribers in Q1 2023. Yet it’s ARPU is at a meager 74 cents.

Disney+ in total has 161 million subscribers as of Q1 2023, yet it’s goals throughout 2023 will be to get its ARPU higher as Disney wants the service to be profitable by fiscal 2024. Could we see another Disney+ price hike? I’d hope not but one has to wonder. We will have to see how the numbers look for Disney+ come Q2 and Q3. I’m expecting improvements across the board. I believe Disney+ in some cases has already reached a ceiling when it comes to subscriber growth, unless it adds a wider range of originals and builds out with a deeper variety of content. It will likely remain where it is at subscriber wise.

Elsewhere, Disney has a decision coming up with Hulu. Will they own 100% of it? It sure looks like they are going to have to pay up. I don’t see Comcast buying Hulu. Sure it can happen but does it make sense? Does it move the needle? Won’t it just be Peacock with a better name and branding? Not to mention would Comcast get to keep the content that is on Hulu or would Disney make a play to get series like Only Murders in the Building and others off of Hulu and onto Disney+ before a sale?

Hulu has always had stronger ARPU than Disney+ due to it being more established and at a higher pricepoint. It also helps Hulu has a more expensive Live TV tier. Hulu sits at 48 million subscribers but how many of those subscribers are subscribed to Disney+ or the Disney Bundle? I’d love to know the crossover.

Disney is in a real no man’s land situation when it comes to Hulu. I don’t think anyone truly knows how that situation will play out. There are so many factors at play.

Another point to note with our Disney Subscriber Dive is that ESPN+ sits at 24 million subscribers during Q1 2023. Disney cares about ESPN and it doesn’t look like they are going to sell it anytime soon despite analysts begging for it. To have nearly 25 million paying for ESPN+ is quite remarkable considering it doesn’t show everything like ESPN. Keeping sports in the mix also broadens Disney’s reach and unlocks different demographics. Disney has to hold on to ESPN until 2027 because ABC has the rights to host the Super Bowl that year, and I don’t want to miss the opportunity to see Disney use its synergy power on the Super Bowl.

Iger’s successor — whoever that may be — will have to determine if it make sense just to combine ESPN+, Hulu, and Disney+ into one super service. It would come at a higher price but the value proposition will be stronger. Especially if more ESPN content and live sports migrate to the streamer. Hulu would cover your adult demo. Disney+ can continue to be the family and franchise play. It may take a while to get there but the merger may be the best way forward for Disney’s streaming efforts.

Be sure to continue to follow Boardwalk Times for more coverage of The Walt Disney Company.

Support Boardwalk Times on Ko-Fi.

If you like this article. Subscribe to my free newsletter Boardwalk Times: Stories from the Seashore, a monthly dose of Disney, its businesses, and the wider themed entertainment industry.

Zach Perilstein is the Editor-in-Chief of the Boardwalk Times

Zach Perilstein
Zach Perilstein
Editor-in-Chief and creator of Boardwalk Times.

Popular Articles