In a piece for Vanity Fair, Lucasfilm President Kathleen Kennedy went on the record and revealed a lesson that the team learned from Solo: A Star Wars Story, Star Wars’ first critical and commercial misfire that derailed the entire strategy for the theatrical Star Wars anthology films.
The lesson that Lucasfilm supposedly learned was that you can’t recast members of the original trilogy.
Essentially they are saying the failure of Solo is on Alden Ehrenreich and Donald Glover for simply not being Harrison Ford and Billy Dee Williams. Mark Hamill returning as Luke Skywalker through CGI de-aging is further proof of Lucasfilm’s new no-recasting strategy.
“There should be moments along the way when you learn things,” Kennedy tells Vanity Fair. “Now it does seem so abundantly clear that we can’t do that.”
I’m thinking Lucasfilm learned the wrong lessons from Solo: A Star Wars Story. As multiple factors plagued Solo’s potential and Alden Ehrenreich’s performance wasn’t one of them. He did his best to capture the Han Solo energy and no one and I mean no one can be Harrison Ford.

I’ll admit seeing Mark Hamill as Luke Skywalker post Return of the Jedi and in The Mandalorian timeline is epic. I also think it’s good for Hamill who seemed unsatisfied with the more gloomy The Last Jedi being his final performance as the Jedi Master.
Seeing post Return of the Jedi Luke Skywalker is freaking awesome and it works for now. I’m also open to if the Filoniverse film — a potential film that teams the original trilogy characters with characters from the animated series and The Mandalorian timeline — comes along that they actually add a real actor to play him.
Speaking of a Filoniverse film? Do you know who would work as Han Solo? Alden Ehrenreich. Do you know who would work as Princess Leia? Billie Lourd. Do you know who would work as Lando? Donald Glover. For Luke, it can be a toss-up. And heck if the Filoniverse film ever happens I doubt the original trilogy characters would be headlining it. I would bet Pedro Pascal’s The Mandalorian would be front and center along with characters like Bo-Katan, Ahsoka, Ezra Bridger, Sabine Wren, and of course Grogu.
If we face the facts and the reality of the situation. If you want more Han Solo it’s extremely unlikely Harrison Ford will do it even if it’s just a check for CGI de-aging work. That man is content playing Indiana Jones and then going to play in the Yellowstone sandbox. Alden Ehrenreich is your best choice and despite reviews, I believe he has the majority of the fans on his side.
Blaming the failure of Solo: A Star Wars Story on the actors isn’t a good look. Especially considering the myriad of factors that led to Solo’s unsuccessful run (although many fans have enjoyed the films and some on social media even tweet out their support via #MakeSolo2Happen).

One of the most gigantic factors was that Solo was originally going to be a Phil Lord and Christopher Miller-directed film. So, it is safe to say that it would’ve been a lot different. I’m thinking it would’ve been more meta and more of a comedy and that was probably something that caught Lucasfilm brass off guard.
But the “creative differences” controversy led to an excruciating production process for new director Ron Howard. In the end, Ron Howard did a fine job and a lot of fans were satisfied. Yet, I think the thought of Lord and Miller’s Solo lingered in the minds of critics and fans while watching Ron Howard’s Solo.
So, yes critically a film that showcases Han Solo’s youth years without Harrison Ford was going to run into some issues without a bold creative direction. Yet, the film might’ve done better financially if it wasn’t released in May 2018. Just think about that insane release slot for a moment.
Solo: A Star Wars Story came out right after Avengers: Infinity War (quite literally one of the biggest films of all time)and Deadpool 2, two films that would make it into the top 10 at the domestic box office for the year. There wasn’t a hunger for a Star Wars film in May at that point and it was also only a few months after the polarizing reception of The Last Jedi.
Lucasfilm thought the lessons learned from Solo were just to use CGI deepfake technology, not recast original trilogy characters, and change creative direction at whim and things will still work.
When in reality the lessons that they should’ve learned were to not make a film about young Han Solo if it didn’t have an incredible hook, don’t meddle with the production process, and don’t schedule a film mere months after another Star Wars film. Let alone have it come out after two major Marvel films. Disney should’ve known better and stepped in. I have no clue what they were thinking about sending Solo out there in that release slot.
To be fair Lucasfilm President Kathleen Kennedy might’ve learned one lesson from Solo: A Star Wars Story that majority could agree with.
“Well, maybe Solo should have been a TV show.”
A Solo Disney+ series would’ve been perfect if they would’ve held off on the idea until Late 2019. Kathleen Kennedy believes they would’ve had the same problem. “But even doing Solo as a TV show without Harrison Ford as Han Solo…it’s the same thinking.” Although one has to wonder if Kennedy is open to making a Disney+ series with Emilia Clarke’s Qi’ra character from Solo. That series wouldn’t have any issues because the character Han Solo wouldn’t need to be involved.
It’s hard to replace Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, and Harrison Ford as Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, and Han Solo. But in order to continue telling stories within that timeline, it’s something that has to be reckoned with. The post-Return of the Jedi and pre-The Force Awakens timeline is too good not to use and in order to tell those stories, you need the big three.
In the end, there were a ton of lessons that Lucasfilm should’ve learned from Solo: A Star Wars Story and maybe they have. Although from what we know currently it seems like they learned the wrong lessons, and that’s unfortunate for everyone who was involved in making Solo.
Zach Perilstein is the Editor-in-Chief of the Boardwalk Times



