With nearly a century of history and film presence, the Walt Disney Company is no stranger to awards season. Winning their first award in 1931 for the short film Flowers and Trees, TWDC has maintained a significant presence as an animated giant in years since. If a Disney film is up for Best Animated Picture, it’s often guaranteed to win, and they’ve cornered the Best Animated Short Category ever since Pixar started using the format to explore and experiment with new techniques of unique animated storytelling.

It’s barely been a competition with Disney, as evident with the 2017 Nominees and Winner for Best Animated Film. Disney-Pixar won with their lovable fim Coco, the story of a Latino child’s adventure through life and a colorful death in pursuit of expression and family. Though amazing in its own right, the film was a surefire win, up against dismal films like The Boss Baby, starring Alec Baldwin as a suit and tie toting baby, and Ferdinand, a film starring John Cena as a bull.
Animated films are rarely given the attention they deserve by the academy, and safe, colorful hits are usually granted the time in the limelight. Though films like The Breadwinner and Loving Vincent were also nominated, they proved far too inaccessible for Academy voters.
Mind you, I appreciate Lee Unkrich, Jason Katz, Matthew Aldrich, and Adrian Molina’s work on this amazing film, and I really enjoyed Coco as an artistic expression of heritage, but it should be realized that this film was the safest bet of the bunch. It was well liked enough to be accepted, but within the confines of traditional children’s animation as to not be alienating to voters.
Herein lies the truth of the Animation Category at the Oscars. Voters tend to pick the Disney film because it’s the “Disney” film. For animation, Disney is a safe bet, and the name is associated with quality animation. For academy voters that don’t take the Animation category seriously, many tend to check the “Disney box” and move on.
Note: I truly hope you feel as annoyed as I do about this; it’s silly that the Oscars treat animation so poorly. For further information, please read the article linked here: https://www.fastcompany.com/40538598/why-the-oscar-rarely-goes-to-indie-noms-for-best-animated-film
As the 2019 Academy Awards approach, new predictions are being made regarding possible nominees. For animation, Disney has had a lackluster year, with two subpar films (The Incredibles 2 and Ralph Breaks the Internet) coasting along without making a significant impact. Critical viewers took issue with the worn out properties being revisited at the hands of a company endlessly looking to profit off of memorability, and popcorn moviegoers didn’t have much to say either.

In fact, this year’s animation award may go to Sony’s psychedelic and loveable brainchild of Bob Persichetti, Peter Ramsey, Rodney Rothman, and Phil Lord, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse. Unique in its style, this film provides experimental animation with an approachable subject that, given the aforementioned Disney films, may give it a strong chance in winning this award.
It should be mentioned that Disney-Pixar’s short film Bao has a strong presence in this year’s animated short film category. The representation within the short, context behind it’s inception, and popularity with audiences may be a good sign for this short’s future.

However, one award that has alluded the Walt Disney Company is the coveted Oscar for “Best Picture” given to the movie the Academy deems the greatest film of the year. A Best Picture nominee alone can distinguish a film for generations, and place it in the public limelight as a piece of respected art in film history. Three Disney films have been nominated for the award (Beauty and the Beast, Up, and Toy Story 3), but none have won so far. Many believe that B&tB was a symbolic nomination, and the other two were nominated because the limit increased from 5 films to 10.
Animated films are often treated like a genre, rather than a medium, which often prevents them from being nominated for Best Picture. Voters will disregard animated films as childish based simply on the way they’re presented.
Disney’s name has clout, and their animated films are regarded with acclaim based on the name alone. If you’re watching a “Disney” or “Disney-Pixar” film, it’s expected to be good. The track record is great, and that provides a sense of legitimacy to the brand. Legitimacy breeds marketability, and Disney benefits on the blind popularity of their properties.
The animation facet of the company has been respected for decades, but this does not hold true for all of the Disney’s endeavors. Specifically, the Marvel branch of entertainment has been an economic powerhouse, but lacks the respect given to other forms of Disney media. Many people treat these outings as “popcorn movies,” or movies that, while entertaining, provide very little beneath the surface.

Film Fans across social media often push the Marvel films aside, noting that they’re simply made to make money, rather than promote any artistic progression or unique ideas. Often, the films are similar to one another, garnering criticism from outlets rather than praise as the animation does.
What remains different this year is the possibility for new legitimacy within the brand. The Golden Globes nominated Black Panther for the Best Picture — Drama category and though it didn’t win, the film’s presence in the category was groundbreaking.
If you had asked any film fanatic years prior if a Marvel movie would have a possible spot as a Best Picture Nominee, most would have shrugged the notion off. These movies were summer blockbusters, not pieces of cinematic art, and many would disregard their presence in award shows as pandering.

Through intense marketing, advertising, and a poignant use of the current political and social climate, Disney managed to push Black Panther over the impossible hurdle and grant it a possibility for success. As evident in the “For Your Consideration” discs given to Academy voters, Marvel-Disney is heavily weighing on the social importance of the movie as to have it stand out for the Oscars. Black Panther heavily focuses on Race, with a diverse cast and socio-political commentary on how other cultures are respected, or even subjugated by the modern world.
Right now, Disney doesn’t see Black Panther as an action film, rather, a moment in film history where representation shows itself in full force. Black Panther isn’t just a Marvel film, but one of the highest grossing films of all time that happen to also feature a diverse cast. The film isn’t just entertaining, it’s important to the world of film itself.
If Black Panther happens to win the award, the Marvel brand will no longer be the monthly installment series it’s perceived as. With a Best Picture award tied to the name, the brand becomes a legitimate staple of film, receiving praise throughout the community and further supporting its spot in contemporary film. It will be far more difficult to argue against the Marvel films, as the “simple popcorn movie” argument doesn’t hold up when Black Panther is recognized by the academy.
As a film buff myself, I wouldn’t necessarily be happy with this decision. Though better than Bohemian Rhapsody and Green Book, Black Panther lacked the nuance delivered by many other films in the category, while failing to have CGI up to modern standards. Black Panther has solid acting, but the directorial style of Ryan Coogler present in his other films was missing here. It felt like Disney handed him THEIR camera, and told him to follow THEIR lead. Black Panther is an important movie, and for that I praise the film, but I don’t think it holds a candle to many of the amazing films we saw this year (If Beale Street Could Talk, Roma, BlackKkKlansman, Isle of Dogs, The Favourite).
What I do recognize is that the Academy will decide as they please. Given the intense social climate around the film, and importance it has to the film industry, AND the amount of money Disney has put into this film’s award season marketing to emphasize the social/political importance of the movie, there remains a possibility that Marvel will take home the gold this year.
Wakanda Forever, I suppose.
Note: As I was writing this article, this article came out from comicbook.com and I highly recommend you read it. Link: https://comicbook.com/marvel/2019/01/07/marvel-studios-kevin-feige-black-panther-most-important-victory-weve-ever-had/
Ryan Dorman is a Columnist and the Content Director for the Boardwalk Times. He can be found on Twitter at @OpentheDorman, and as a host of the Boardwalk Talk podcast on iTunes.



